• Home
    • facebook
    • instagram
    • bluesky
    • goodreads
    • mail
    • ko-fi

Heise Reads & Recommends

A School Librarian Sharing Books & #ClassroomBookADay

  • Heise Reads & Recommends
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Recommended Reads
  • #ClassroomBookADay
    • What is #ClassroomBookADay?
    • Getting Started with #ClassroomBookADay
    • #ClassroomBookADay Resources
    • #cbadSpotlight
    • #ClassroomBookADay Book Recommendations
  • Resources
    • Slides & Docs
    • Author / Illustrator Interviews & Guest Posts
  • Consulting
    • Published Works
    • Conference Sessions & Presentations
    • Workshops & Webinars
    • #ClassroomBookADay Presentations

ARTICLE 5 by Kristen Simmons

May 10, 2012

Title: ARTICLE 5
Author: Kristen Simmons
Publisher: Tor Teen
Release Date: Janurary 31, 2012
Number of Pages: 364
Source of Book: Finished hardcover signed at the Tor booth at the IRA Convention

New York, Los Angeles, and Washington, D.C., have been abandoned.

The Bill of Rights has been revoked, and replaced with the Moral Statutes.

There are no more police—instead, there are soldiers. There are no more fines for bad behavior—instead, there are arrests, trials, and maybe worse. People who get arrested usually don’t come back.

Seventeen-year-old Ember Miller is old enough to remember that things weren’t always this way. Living with her rebellious single mother, it’s hard for her to forget that people weren’t always arrested for reading the wrong books or staying out after dark. It’s hard to forget that life in the United States used to be different.

Ember has perfected the art of keeping a low profile. She knows how to get the things she needs, like food stamps and hand-me-down clothes, and how to pass the random home inspections by the military. Her life is as close to peaceful as circumstances allow.

That is, until her mother is arrested for noncompliance with Article 5 of the Moral Statutes. And one of the arresting officers is none other than Chase Jennings—the only boy Ember has ever loved.

So I’m a little torn with this book. One the one hand, once I got into it I couldn’t stop reading it. I was sneaking it in and staying up too late to keep reading. On the other hand, I didn’t completely connect with the characters in the beginning and the writing style felt a little stilted and obvious to me. Also, I felt it was pretty predictable. ARTICLE 5 has an intriguing premise for a dystopian, and I do love dystopian books, and I had a lot of hope for where it would go, but it felt more like a road-tripping story for much of the book, so I struggled with figuring out how I really felt.

I really liked the parts where it was more about fighting against the governmental system. The bad guys were definite baddies (including the government overall!), but sometimes I wasn’t sure if a new (or old) character would turn out to really be bad or good, which is a good thing. I did connect more with the characters after the halfway point of the book, and I was invested in them getting past their own individual demons to see what they have with each other. The relationship between Ember and Chase had me wanting to root for them, wanting to scream at them, and wanting to cry for them alternatingly throughout the book. And I really had a hard time putting it down after I got to a certain point, and then I was sneaking in every minute of reading that I could so I could find out what would happen. Both Ember and Chase have some deep emotional journeys they need to travel in this book, and by the end, I was excited to see where they would go next.

Overall, I will definitely get the next book, BREAKING POINT, to find out what will happen, especially since I was left with a bit of a feeling of this book being longer than it necessarily needed to be – by the end I felt like it was really a big book of exposition setting things up for an entire series. I really liked Ember’s strength and determination by the end of the book, and I do adore my tragic heroes and Chase definitely fits that bill, so I want to know what is going to happen in their lives next, now that I think the real action will be starting.

I’m kind of between recommending and highly recommending this book. As I write about it, I feel like my rating gets higher as I think back over all of the things I liked, but the writing style and the difficulty really connecting and the predictability makes me want to lower it a little. So, since I can’t decide, I’m putting both. I shared these thoughts with my students today and asked if someone would read it and let me know a student’s thoughts. It was snapped up right away by one as soon as I mentioned the angsty romance aspect. Can’t wait to hear what a teen thinks.

«
»

Filed Under: Other

Comments

  1. The Insouciant Sophisticate says

    May 11, 2012 at 2:01 am

    I really didn't like the road tripping aspect of this book; I think I tend to prefer dystopias where they stay in one place and especially when they have excellent writing to lift them up.

  • facebook
  • instagram
  • bluesky
  • goodreads
  • mail
  • ko-fi

Search

select

shop

Subscribe

statement

Views expressed within these pages are personal & do not represent that of my employer.

Recent Reads

Loujain Dreams of Sunflowers
Mama in Congress: Rashida Tlaib's Journey to Washington
I Lived Inside a Whale
The Last Slice: A Three Kings Day Treat
Yusra Swims
One Wish: Fatima al-Fihri and the World's Oldest University
Dounia and the Magic Seeds
Nour's Secret Library
Swimming Toward a Dream: Yusra Mardini's Incredible Journey from Refugee to Olympic Swimmer
Eleven Words for Love: A Journey Through Arabic Expressions of Love
Not Yet: The Story of an Unstoppable Skater
The Book That Almost Rhymed
I Am Odd, I Am New
Brody the Lion Sometimes I ROAR!: Helping children with autism, anxiety, and big emtions cope with transitions and changes
Arab Arab All Year Long!
My Brother Otto and the Birthday Party
How Are You, Verity?
We Are a Class
I Want to Read All the Books
The Brightness Between Us

Latest Resources

Instagram Posts

Current commute audiobook: @jordanchiles I'M THAT Current commute audiobook: @jordanchiles I'M THAT GIRL 🤸🏿‍♀️🥉
Following that #BlackHistoryMonth ➡️ #WomensHistoryMonth flow.
#ReadAcrossAmerica Day is Monday. How are you cele #ReadAcrossAmerica Day is Monday. How are you celebrating literacy? If you need some ideas, consider Reading Across the Diverse Regions of America with titles set in various states. 
Grab the link in bio / on my blog.
bit.ly/heiseRAA2024
#WNDB #ClassroomBookADay #LibraryLife #LibrariansOfInstagram #TeachersOfInstagram
Weekend mindfulness task accomplished.✅ Lego wil Weekend mindfulness task accomplished.✅
Lego wildflower bouquet from the niblings. 💕 Headed to my library tomorrow.💐
Current commute audiobook read. "The Small and the Current commute audiobook read. "The Small and the Mighty is the encouragement we all need in an age of doomscrolling and division."
Being reminded of our common humanity & inspired by the hope of it all from America's Government Teacher™️ @sharonsaysso. ❤️🤍💙
#amreading #audiobook #bookaday #ReadingWithMyEars
Wishing I was back here with @jenseiler79 & @msgue Wishing I was back here with @jenseiler79 & @msguerrette!!🫶🏻 Holding tight to the small joys & friendships that will get us through to the other side of all of this.
Kicking off #BlackHistoryMonth with @elaineweltero Kicking off #BlackHistoryMonth with @elainewelteroth's More Than Enough for this week's commute audiobook.
#WNDB #LibraryLife #HeiseReads
It's the start of #BlackHistoryMonth & one way you It's the start of #BlackHistoryMonth & one way you can support diverse books and ensuring that we continue to have Black creatives in publishing is by reading, recommending, sharing, reviewing, and purchasing their books. And if sharing read aloud videos, please seek out ones that abide by copyright and don't take away from their ability to earn an income from their writing & art.
Due to committee commitments this year, I can't post about 2025 books, but I can share my resource from last year. This Virtual Picture Book Read Aloud Library is a Google Slideshow covering 233 titles, in 7 categories, with book covers linking directly to copyright-compliant video read alouds of recommended picture books. 
Categories include:
(a purposeful, intentional start with positive portrayals)
Black Joy & Magic
Families
Natural Hair
Empowering Stories
Black History
Excellence / Innovators / History Makers (Biographies)
Racial / Community Awareness
Use for February and any month! 
Blog Post: heisereads.com/bhm2024-ralib/
Shop Link: bit.ly/heisebhm2024
#ClassroomBookADay #WNDB #LibraryLife #KidLit  #TeachersOfInstagram #LibrariansOfInstagram #TeachersFollowTeachers #HeiseReads
The most exciting day of the year is here - it's t The most exciting day of the year is here - it's the ALA Youth Media Awards announcements! And we get to be in the room where it happens! 
This is like the Oscars / Super Bowl / "whatever big award honor thing you can think of" for the children's literature community.
An extra exciting way to head into the start of my Caldecott Committee year. 🏅
#ALAYMA25 #ALALLX25 #NerdyBookClub #LibraryLife #HeiseReads
Current status. Writing & finalizing #NCTE25 propo Current status.
Writing & finalizing #NCTE25 proposals poolside at my parents' house in PHX with @msguerrette & @jenseiler79 before heading back down to #ALALLX25 this afternoon.
It's too cold to have school, but it's perfect tim It's too cold to have school, but it's perfect timing to get to stay home curled up under my @unhide Marshmallow Blanket in my @softiespjs Marshmallow Slouch Turtleneck Lounger on Onyx Storm release day. 
#amreading #OnyxStorm #bookaday #HeiseReads
Follow @heisereads on Instagram
Copyright © 2025 · Website Design By Jumping Jax Designs